10 Must-See Stops on the HandMade & HomeGrown in Fairfield County Trail

When local craft meets community spirit, Fairfield County shines. From cozy cafes to artist studios and sun-kissed farms, these ten stops on our HandMade & HomeGrown Trail are all about supporting local makers, savoring homegrown flavors, and discovering hidden gems you’ll want to brag about to your friends.

Provisions Bakery & Deli – Lancaster

Walking into Provisions feels a little like stepping into the heartbeat of downtown Lancaster. There’s a familiar hum in the air—espresso machines steaming, laughter spilling from nearby tables, and the clatter of plates stacked high with made-from-scratch goodness. Housed in the same charming building that once held Four Reasons (a name the locals still whisper with a hint of nostalgia), Provisions has taken the reins and elevated the experience without losing its warmth.

This isn’t your average sandwich shop. It’s a bustling community hub where bakers arrive before sunrise to coax golden crusts from the ovens and chefs pile each sandwich high with top-tier meats, cheeses, and crisp produce—always fresh, always made with care. Whether you’re grabbing a loaded breakfast sandwich on your way to the farmers market, lingering over a lunch meeting with friends, or popping in for a salad and a bottle of wine to go, Provisions always delivers.

Beyond the counter, you’ll find shelves stocked with curated pantry staples, grab-and-go meals for busy nights, and even espresso drinks worth writing home about. It’s the kind of place that makes you wish you were a local—if only so you’d have an excuse to stop by every day.

Double Edge Brewing Co. – Lancaster

If Provisions is Lancaster’s go-to for fueling up, then Double Edge is where locals go to wind down—and maybe get a little loud in the best way possible. Nestled in the heart of downtown, Double Edge Brewing Co. isn’t just a craft brewery—it’s a social scene, a gathering spot, and a celebration of what it means to be local.

The beer? Outstanding. Small batch, thoughtfully brewed, and full of creativity. You’ll find familiar favorites on tap, alongside seasonal rotations and limited releases that reflect the personality of the town itself—unpretentious, bold, and a little quirky. But the real magic of Double Edge is how well they play with others. This is a place that thrives on collaboration, whether it’s pairing up with local food trucks for themed nights, hosting tap takeovers with fellow brewers, or planning creative events with artists, vendors, and nonprofits from around the county.

There’s almost always something happening here. From live music and trivia nights to pop-up shops and beer release parties, the calendar is packed with ways to connect and kick back. The outdoor seating is perfect for people-watching in the warmer months, and inside, the cozy taproom hums with conversation and the clink of glasses. For visitors, it’s an invitation to experience Lancaster like a local. For locals, it’s a guaranteed good time and a sure bet you’ll run into someone you know.

If you want a taste of Fairfield County’s community vibe in a pint glass, this is where you start.

Farmer’s Country Store – Lancaster

Step inside The Farmer’s Country Store and it feels like you’ve entered a beloved neighbor’s home—if that neighbor happened to be a master quilter, creative genius, and passionate collector of all things handmade and heartfelt. Tucked just outside downtown Lancaster, this cozy shop has been a local treasure since 1973, welcoming generations of shoppers, crafters, and kindred spirits who share a love for timeless traditions and beautifully made things.

The store is packed to the rafters in the best possible way. Every corner, shelf, and nook holds a little surprise—Americana decor, folk art, hand-thrown pottery, primitive finds, quilt shop-exclusive fabrics, and seasonal items that’ll make your home feel warm and welcoming year-round. There’s a clear love in how the space is curated—intentionally, passionately, and with a strong nod to community roots.

But this isn’t just a shop. It’s a gathering place. The Farmer’s Country Store is known for its quilting classes, stitching circles, and hands-on workshops that connect like-minded makers in a relaxed, welcoming setting. Whether you’re just getting into the art of quilting or you’ve got decades of stitching under your belt, you’ll find inspiration—and plenty of encouragement—within these walls.

Locals know it as a go-to for meaningful gifts and home accents that tell a story. Visitors quickly realize they’ve stumbled upon something special. It’s the kind of place you wander into on a whim and leave with a bag full of treasures—and a heart full of nostalgia.

Gay Fad Studios – Lancaster

Gay Fad Studios makes a bold first impression. Bright, colorful, and impeccably styled, this modern boutique-gallery hybrid brings a sleek, upscale energy to Lancaster’s creative corridor—while giving a respectful (and fabulous) nod to the past.

Originally founded in the 1940s by trailblazing designer Fran Taylor, Gay Fad Studios was one of the earliest woman-owned businesses to make a national name in hand-painted glassware. Today, owners David and Jason have revived the brand with a fresh perspective—reimagining its iconic designs in a space that feels both high-end and welcoming.

They’re the kind of hosts who make you want to linger. Whether you’re a mid-century design aficionado or just curious about Lancaster’s glass town heritage, you’ll leave with more than a shopping bag—you’ll leave with stories. The on-site museum walks you through the brand’s rich history, and the shop itself offers an eye-catching mix of original Gay Fad pieces, vintage finds, and curated decor that blends nostalgia with modern taste.

It’s not what you expect when you think of a “studio,” and that’s what makes it so unforgettable.

Keller Market House – Lancaster

If the Handmade & Homegrown Trail had a headquarters, it’d be Keller Market House. Set in a beautifully restored historic building just steps from Main St., this year-round indoor market is all about community connection and local pride. It’s the kind of place where farmers know your name, bakers remember your favorite scone, and every dollar spent stays close to home.

Inside, the shelves are lined with local produce, pasture-raised meats, handmade cheeses, fresh-baked breads, small-batch pantry goods, and an ever-changing mix of artisan wares. You’ll also find items you didn’t even know you needed—locally roasted coffee, herbal tonics, hard-to-find spices, floral bouquets, and sustainably produced wines from just down the road.

But Keller Market House is more than just a place to shop—it’s a gathering space. It’s where makers meet buyers, neighbors swap recipes, and the values of slow food and sustainability come to life. From cooking demos in the community kitchen to collaborative pop-up events, Keller is always stirring up something special.

Fairfield County feels a little smaller—in the best way—when you’re at Keller. It’s a reminder of what’s possible when a community supports its own, and it’s proof that shopping local isn’t just a trend—it’s a way of life.

Mud Gallery – Lancaster

Mud Gallery isn’t just a place—it’s a vibe. Tucked into a colorful corner of downtown Lancaster, this artist-owned studio and shop invites you to slow down, explore, and connect with the creative spirit of Fairfield County.

Inside, you’ll find the signature Primitive Mud Pottery of artist Teresa Speakman—earthy, textured, beautifully imperfect pieces that feel as good in your hands as they look on your table. Every shelf tells a story, showcasing an eclectic mix of handcrafted ceramics, wall art, and functional pieces made by local artists who pour their heart into their craft.

Want to try your hand at crafting something special? Mud Gallery’s pottery “playshops” are a chance to get a little messy and a lot inspired. These classes are designed for anyone—from complete beginners to those who haven’t touched clay since high school. It’s less about perfection, more about the joy of creating something with your own two hands.

Mud Gallery is also home to Full Circle Peace, a haven for mindful living practices, guided meditation, and workshops that support whole-person wellness. It’s a space where art, intention, and community beautifully collide.

Whether you’re on the hunt for a one-of-a-kind gift, looking to add soul to your space, or just want to take a break from the bustle of your day, Mud Gallery offers a warm, earthy pause—a place where creativity feels grounding, joyful, and just a little bit magical.

Zoetic Connections – Lancaster

Zoetic Connections feels like a hidden gem tucked into downtown Lancaster’s ever-growing creative corridor. Walk through the door and you’re immediately greeted with color, texture, and warmth—from glittering crystals and incense to locally made jewelry and handcrafted gifts. It’s part apothecary, part artisan boutique, and entirely a reflection of the owner’s passion for meaningful, soul-nourishing products.

Formerly known as Gemini Gems & Creations, Zoetic Connections has evolved into a haven for anyone craving a little magic, mindfulness, or artistic spark. Whether you’re shopping for a one-of-a-kind gift or on a personal quest for grounding and good vibes, this place just has that certain energy—authentic, inspiring, and a little mystical in all the right ways.

It’s the kind of shop you wander into for one thing and leave with three more—because everything seems to speak to you. And if you happen to chat with the staff (you should), you’ll feel like you’ve made a new friend by the time you walk out.

Ochs Fruit Farm – Lancaster

A Fairfield County institution since 1872, Ochs Fruit Farm is one of those places that locals grow up visiting and never outgrow. Just outside downtown Lancaster, this family-run orchard spans over 50 acres of fruit trees and gardens—and it’s as picturesque as it is productive.

Ochs is best known for its apples (over 100 varieties!) and peaches (15 kinds), but there’s also an incredible bounty of pears, peppers, tomatoes, and other just-picked vegetables depending on the season. The experience is delightfully old-school in the best way—no frills, no fuss, just the kind of fresh, honest produce that tastes like childhood summers and Sunday pies.

In the fall, the orchard buzzes with pick-your-own flower fields and crisp, cool air filled with the scent of ripe apples. Come for the fruit stand, stay for the views, and leave with a trunk full of goodies and a smile on your face. This is what it means to shop local—and eat local—at its finest.

Hidden View Farmstead – Bremen

If you’re looking for high-quality, locally sourced groceries straight from the land (and the hands that care for it), make your way to Hidden View Farmstead. This family-run farm in Bremen is all about sustainability, transparency, and producing food you can feel good about feeding your family.

Their secret? Regenerative farming practices and hydroponic growing systems that make their crisp, chemical-free lettuce and seasonal produce some of the freshest you’ll find anywhere. Add in all-natural, pasture-raised meats, farm-fresh eggs, and locally sourced dairy, and you’ve got yourself a true one-stop market for handmade and homegrown essentials.

Fall fun takes the spotlight starting September 6, when the pumpkin patch opens and Hidden View transforms into your go-to spot for all things autumn—think crisp air, cider in hand, a corn maze challenge, and kids racing to find the biggest pumpkin in the patch, cozy vibes included. A petting zoo is included! 

It’s not just a farm—it’s a wholesome experience rooted in the values that make Fairfield County feel like home. Come for the groceries, stay for the heart.

The Humble Crate Artisan Marketplace – Pickerington

The Humble Crate is proof that handmade and heartmade go hand in hand. Located in Olde Pickerington Village, this artisan marketplace showcases more than 80 local artists and makers under one roof. The space is bright, friendly, and full of creative energy—perfect for those who love to shop with intention and support their community.

You’ll find everything from leather goods and woodcraft to textiles, stained glass, jewelry, home décor, and delicious Ohio-made snacks. It’s like the best parts of a craft fair, farmers market, and indie boutique all rolled into one.

Every product has a story, and the folks at Humble Crate love to share them. Whether you’re hunting for a unique housewarming gift, a meaningful souvenir, or just want to wander and see what speaks to you, this is one of those places where you’re guaranteed to find something special.

Pro Tip: While you’re in Pickerington, don’t miss The Molt and Moon across the street—another gem offering curated fashion and home goods. This part of town is quietly becoming a destination in its own right, and The Humble Crate is leading the charge.

Runners-up for our Top 10 list include even more local favorites just a short stroll away: grab a small-batch brew at Combustion Brewery, pop into FYN & Co. Mercantile for thoughtful gifts and seasonal finds, or treat yourself to a handcrafted pastry and latte from Porter’s Coffee House & Bakery. Don’t forget, there’s always room for ice cream, and Johnson’s Real Ice Cream will have you coming back for more! Olde Pickerington Village is full of surprises—plan to linger.

• Plan your day: Start in Lancaster (Provisions, Keller, Mud Gallery, Gay Fad, Zoetic, Ochs), meander out to the country for Hidden View Farmstead in Bremen, then swing up to Pickerington for The Humble Crate and so much more!
  
• Get the inside scoop: Download the Visit Fairfield County App—map your day, check in at each stop, collect ideas from other makers.
  
• Need extra help? Head to the Visitor Center in Lancaster for printed maps, trail tips, and insider-only suggestions.